The Island of Doctor Moreau Study Guide
Color Theme
Font Style
Sans Serif System Mono Accessible
Text Size

Chapter VIII — The Crying of the Puma

Chapter Summary

Montgomery joins Prendick for lunch, served by his strange attendant. Prendick presses Montgomery about the attendant's pointed, furry ears and unsettling eyes; Montgomery feigns ignorance, but Prendick suspects deception. Montgomery also tries to draw him into a discussion about alcohol, and says that Moreau is too absorbed in his work to join them. Throughout the meal, agonised cries from a puma being vivisected in the enclosure interrupt the conversation, visibly irritating Montgomery.

After Montgomery leaves, the puma's cries intensify until Prendick can no longer endure them indoors. He steps outside, where the sound strikes him as though "all the pain in the world had found a voice." He reflects that suffering becomes unbearable only when it is audible, and he walks until the cries are out of earshot.

Translation Style
✨ Character Voice Translations PREMIUM
Original Text
Montgomery interrupted my tangle of mystification and suspicion about one o’clock, and his grotesque attendant followed him with a tray bearing bread, some herbs and other eatables, a flask of whiskey, a jug of water, and three glasses and knives. I glanced askance at this strange creature, and found him watching me with his queer, restless eyes. Montgomery said he would lunch with me, but that Moreau was too preoccupied with some work to come. “Moreau!” said I. “I know that name.” “The devil you do!” said he. “What an ass I was to mention it to you! I might have thought. Anyhow, it will give you an inkling of our—mysteries. Whiskey?” “No, thanks; I’m an abstainer.” “I wish I’d been. But it’s no use locking the door after the steed is stolen. It was that infernal stuff which led to my coming here,—that, and a foggy night. I thought myself in luck at the time, when Moreau offered to get me off. It’s queer—” “Montgomery,” said I, suddenly, as the outer door closed, “why has your man pointed ears?” “Damn!” he said, over his first mouthful of food. He stared at me for a moment, and then repeated, “Pointed ears?” “Little points to them,” said I, as calmly as possible, with a catch in my breath; “and a fine black fur at the edges?” He helped himself to whiskey and water with great deliberation. “I was under the impression—that his hair covered his ears.” “I saw them as he stooped by me to put that coffee you sent to me on the table. And his eyes shine in the dark.” By this time Montgomery had recovered from the surprise of my question. “I always thought,” he said deliberately, with a certain accentuation of his flavouring of lisp, “that there _was_ something the matter with his ears, from the way he covered them. What were they like?” I was persuaded from his manner that this ignorance was a pretence. Still, I could hardly tell the man that I thought him a liar. “Pointed,” I said; “rather small and furry,—distinctly furry. But the whole man is one of the strangest beings I ever set eyes on.” A sharp, hoarse cry of animal pain came from the enclosure behind us. Its depth and volume testified to the puma. I saw Montgomery wince. “Yes?” he said. “Where did you pick up the creature?” “San Francisco. He’s an ugly brute, I admit. Half-witted, you know. Can’t remember where he came from. But I’m used to him, you know. We both are. How does he strike you?” “He’s unnatural,” I said. “There’s something about him—don’t think me fanciful, but it gives me a nasty little sensation, a tightening of my muscles, when he comes near me. It’s a touch—of the diabolical, in fact.” Montgomery had stopped eating while I told him this. “Rum!” he said. “_I_ can’t see it.” He resumed his meal. “I had no idea of it,” he said, and masticated. “The crew of the schooner must have felt it the same. Made a dead set at the poor devil. You saw the captain?” Suddenly the puma howled again, this time more painfully. Montgomery swore under his breath. I had half a mind to attack him about the men on the beach. Then the poor brute within gave vent to a series of short, sharp cries. “Your men on the beach,” said I; “what race are they?” “Excellent fellows, aren’t they?” said he, absentmindedly, knitting his brows as the animal yelled out sharply. I said no more. There was another outcry worse than the former. He looked at me with his dull grey eyes, and then took some more whiskey. He tried to draw me into a discussion about alcohol, professing to have saved my life with it. He seemed anxious to lay stress on the fact that I owed my life to him. I answered him distractedly. Presently our meal came to an end; the misshapen monster with the pointed ears cleared the remains away, and Montgomery left me alone in the room again. All the time he had been in a state of ill-concealed irritation at the noise of the vivisected puma. He had spoken of his odd want of nerve, and left me to the obvious application. I found myself that the cries were singularly irritating, and they grew in depth and intensity as the afternoon wore on. They were painful at first, but their constant resurgence at last altogether upset my balance. I flung aside a crib of Horace I had been reading, and began to clench my fists, to bite my lips, and to pace the room. Presently I got to stopping my ears with my fingers. The emotional appeal of those yells grew upon me steadily, grew at last to such an exquisite expression of suffering that I could stand it in that confined room no longer. I stepped out of the door into the slumberous heat of the late afternoon, and walking past the main entrance—locked again, I noticed—turned the corner of the wall. The crying sounded even louder out of doors. It was as if all the pain in the world had found a voice. Yet had I known such pain was in the next room, and had it been dumb, I believe—I have thought since—I could have stood it well enough. It is when suffering finds a voice and sets our nerves quivering that this pity comes troubling us. But in spite of the brilliant sunlight and the green fans of the trees waving in the soothing sea-breeze, the world was a confusion, blurred with drifting black and red phantasms, until I was out of earshot of the house in the chequered wall.
Source text: Project Gutenberg #159. Public domain worldwide.
Modern English
Select a style above to load the modern English translation.

This chapter functions as a carefully constructed threshold of revelation: Prendick accumulates evidence — the attendant's pointed ears, shining eyes, and fur — that something is profoundly wrong on the island, yet the full truth is withheld. Wells sustains dramatic irony by allowing the reader to sense what Prendick cannot yet name. Montgomery's studied evasions and deliberate pauses — "He helped himself to whiskey and water with great deliberation" — dramatise the conspiracy of silence that governs the island, making the social ritual of lunch a performance of concealment.

The puma's cries operate as the chapter's dominant structural device, punctuating dialogue and finally overwhelming it entirely. Wells uses the animal's suffering as an acoustic intrusion of the hidden laboratory into the domestic space of the meal, collapsing the boundary between civilised routine and brutal experiment. The escalating cries mirror Prendick's own psychological deterioration, moving him from distraction to physical agitation to flight — a trajectory that prefigures his later moral crisis.

Prendick's meditation near the chapter's close — "It is when suffering finds a voice and sets our nerves quivering that this pity comes troubling us" — is one of Wells's most philosophically charged passages. It engages the Victorian debate over vivisection directly, suggesting that moral sympathy is triggered by audible expression rather than by the mere fact of pain. This implicates the reader: we too respond to the voiced cry, raising questions about the limits and mechanisms of empathy.

Montgomery's backstory — ruin through alcohol, rescue by Moreau — establishes him as a fallen figure whose dependency on Moreau mirrors the Beast People's subjugation. His repeated recourse to whiskey during the chapter reinforces his weakness and his need to dull perception, contrasting with Prendick's abstinence and heightened sensory alertness. The detail that it was "a foggy night" that brought him here links moral obscurity to literal obscurity, a characteristic Wellsian compression of the figurative and literal.

The attendant — described as a "misshapen monster" and a "grotesque" — embodies the chapter's uncanny. His physical anomalies (pointed ears, fur, shining eyes) are described with clinical precision, anticipating the novel's later revelations about Moreau's surgical art. By placing this figure in a domestic servant's role, Wells intensifies the horror through incongruity: the monstrous is embedded in the mundane, serving bread and clearing plates, making the familiar strange in the manner Freud would later theorise as unheimlich.

Loading quotes...

Loading tags...

Ask the Reader

Click any tag to explore where it appears across the book, then ask the Reader to explain how it works in this chapter.

Exploring tag...
The Reader's Take
Ask the Reader to explain how this element appears in this chapter
Click a tag to search.
Ask the Reader about this chapter
Type at least 2 characters to search
Characters & Figures
Loading figures...
✎ Mr. Shifflett's Note
SIS Teachers
Sign in with your @siskorea.org email for free full access to this guide and all GradeWise study guides — every chapter, translation, and premium feature.
Sign In with SIS Email