This scene is built on the comic device of double discourse: every exchange operates simultaneously on a literal and a covert level. Lucentio's Latin construal—drawn from Ovid's Heroides—functions as a cipher, and Bianca's counter-construal reveals that she has decoded it perfectly. Shakespeare thus dramatises language as seduction, showing that wit and linguistic dexterity are the true currency of courtship in Padua. The scene rewards close reading because meaning is always layered: what is said for Hortensio's ears differs entirely from what is communicated between the two lovers.Bianca's behaviour here complicates the conventional portrait of the obedient younger sister. Her opening declaration—'I am no breeching scholar in the schools; / I'll not be tied to hours nor 'pointed times, / But learn my lessons as I please myself'—asserts a quiet but firm autonomy. She manages two competing suitors with cool efficiency, and her measured response to Lucentio ('I know you not … I trust you not … presume not … despair not') shows strategic intelligence rather than passive receptivity. This anticipates the play's broader interrogation of whether female compliance is ever as straightforward as male characters assume.Hortensio's rewritten gamut is a miniature emblem of art pressed into the service of desire....
Act III, Scene 1
Scene Summary
Lucentio (disguised as the tutor Cambio) and Hortensio (disguised as the musician Licio) quarrel over who shall instruct Bianca first. Bianca asserts her own authority, settles the dispute by directing Hortensio to tune his instrument while she takes her Latin lesson. During the lesson, Lucentio encodes his true identity and his love into a construal of Ovid, and Bianca responds in kind—cautiously acknowledging him while urging secrecy.
Hortensio then presents Bianca with a musical scale he has rewritten as a love-plea, which she dismisses. Each suitor privately suspects the other of courting her. A servant interrupts to summon Bianca to help prepare for Katharina's wedding the next day. After she exits, Hortensio delivers a jealous soliloquy, vowing to abandon Bianca if she proves faithless.
"I am no breeching scholar in the schools; I'll not be tied to hours nor 'pointed times, But learn my lessons as I please myself." — Bianca (3.1)
"'Hic ibat,' as I told you before, 'Simois,' I am Lucentio, 'hic est,' son unto Vincentio of Pisa, 'Sigeia tellus,' disguised thus to get your love." — Lucentio (3.1)
"'Hic ibat Simois,' I know you not, 'hic est Sigeia tellus,' I trust you not; 'Hic steterat Priami,' take heed he hear us not, 'regia,' presume not, 'celsa senis,' despair not." — Bianca (3.1)
"The base is right; 'tis the base knave that jars." — Hortensio (3.1)
"Call you this gamut? tut, I like it not: Old fashions please me best; I am not so nice, To change true rules for old inventions." — Bianca (3.1)
"How fiery and forward our pedant is! Now, for my life, the knave doth court my love: Pedascule, I'll watch you better yet." — Hortensio (3.1)
"Yet if thy thoughts, Bianca, be so humble To cast thy wandering eyes on every stale, Seize thee that list: if once I find thee ranging, Hortensio will be quit with thee by changing." — Hortensio (3.1)
Click any tag to explore where it appears across the play, then ask the Bard to explain how it works in this scene.